Active methodologies · Guide and tool

Challenge-Based Learning (CBL): what it is, its phases and how to frame a good challenge

A practical guide for teachers and academic teams: the phases of CBL, how to write a challenge that does not hand over the solution and how to go from an idea to a challenge your students truly experience, with teams, deliverables and assessment.

In a nutshell

Challenge-based learning is a methodology in which students tackle a real, relevant challenge connected to their surroundings, and discover the solution through research. The teacher sets the challenge but never defines the final product: students decide what to create.

The phases

Seven phases, from problem to solution

This is the structure BeChallenge uses for a complete experience. The highlighted phases include a deliverable: that is where the evidence of learning is produced.

  1. DiscoveryEach person researches the problem on their own before working as a team.
  2. TeamsTeams are formed and roles are assigned.
  3. IdeationThe team generates ideas and chooses a proposed solution.
  4. FeedbackThe teacher, peers or external mentors give their views on the proposal.
  5. PrototypeThe team builds and tests its solution.
  6. VotingSolutions are presented and put to a vote.
  7. AssessmentSelf-assessment, peer assessment and assessment of competencies.

Short on time? The same challenge can be run in 5 phases (Discover, Team, Ideate, Prototype, Assess) or in 3 (Team, Prototype, Assess).

How to set it up well

Three pieces: need, essential question and challenge

This is the structure BeChallenge uses to design every challenge. The key to CBL lies in the third piece: the challenge is written without anticipating the solution, so that students propose their own.

1 · The need

Identify and define the problem to solve.

Problem situation + affected group + context + impact

Lack of access to digital learning resources limits the technology skills and training opportunities of students in rural communities.

2 · The essential question

A central question that guides the entire process.

How + desired action + affected group + context + purpose?

How can we make digital learning resources accessible to rural students, given the infrastructure constraints?

3 · The challenge

The challenge itself, without defining the final solution.

Action verb + motivating action + affected group + inspiring goal

Promote healthy digital habits among university students under high technology-related stress to strengthen their well-being.

A good challenge never includes words like "system", "campaign", "app" or "platform": if it does, it is already giving away the solution.

In secondary school

  • Well framed: "How can we improve air quality in classrooms to support concentration and well-being?"
  • Poorly framed: "Design a ventilation system for the classrooms." It prescribes the solution.
  • Why it works: Students can arrive at a variety of solutions: air-purifying plants, ventilation protocols, CO₂ sensors, awareness campaigns…

At university

  • Well framed: "How can we reduce the environmental impact of a local textile company while keeping it competitive?"
  • Poorly framed: "Implement a wastewater recycling system." It prescribes the solution.
  • Why it works: It opens the door to exploring the circular economy, energy efficiency, sustainable materials or reverse logistics. The solution emerges from research.
AI Experience Designer

From an idea to a challenge ready for your class

You enter the topic and the level. The BeChallenge Designer proposes a complete challenge following the CBL phases: need, essential question, interim deliverables, timing, a rubric and a guide for you. You review it, change it and launch it.

Choose an example:

Design my own →
app.bechallenge.io · AI Experience DesignerExample
An example of what the Designer creates. In your trial, it builds one for your topic and you can edit every part of it.
What if I just ask ChatGPT?

An AI writes you an idea. BeChallenge puts it into action.

A general-purpose AI

  • Gives you back a document with an idea.
  • You have to organize teams, submissions and deadlines separately.
  • You cannot see who did what within each team.
  • Assessment ends up in a spreadsheet, if anywhere.

BeChallenge

  • The experience is already structured into phases, with deliverables and a rubric.
  • You share it with a code: your students join and form teams.
  • Every submission, comment and contribution is recorded.
  • Self-assessment, peer assessment and your own assessment generate evidence of competencies.
Projects, challenges, cases and service-learning

How do active methodologies differ?

All four put students at the center and rely on teamwork. The big difference lies in the final product: whether it is defined, discovered, analyzed or delivered as a service.

MethodologyThe final productStudents…Key difference
Project-Based Learning Defined from the start: a documentary, prototype, campaign…Develop a project that demonstrates mastery of competencies.The teacher specifies the type of deliverable.
Challenge-Based Learning Not defined: it emerges from research.Discover the solution and decide what to create.The teacher sets the challenge, but never the product.
Case studies A reasoned analysis: a report, diagnosis or decision proposal.Analyze a real or simulated case and make well-grounded decisions.Nothing new is created: an existing situation is analyzed.
Service-Learning A real service to a community, with measurable impact.Serve a community while developing competencies.There are real beneficiaries outside the classroom.
How it is assessed

Assess the process, not just the final result

With AI, anyone can produce a final piece of work in minutes. What demonstrates learning is evidence of the process: who did what, when and how.

Rubric for each phase

Criteria visible from the start, linked to each deliverable.

360° assessment

Self-assessment, peer assessment, teacher and external mentors, weighted the way you decide.

Evidence of competencies

Every assessment adds to the student's graduate profile.

How to assess competencies across the whole institution →

Frequently asked questions

What people ask most

What is challenge-based learning?

It is a methodology in which students tackle a real challenge and discover the solution through research. The teacher sets the challenge but does not define the final product.

What are the phases of challenge-based learning?

In BeChallenge, a complete challenge has seven phases: discovery, teams, ideation, feedback, prototype, voting and assessment. Shorter challenges use five or three.

What is the difference between challenge-based and project-based learning?

In challenge-based learning, the final product is not defined: students discover what to create. In project-based learning, the product is defined from the start.

How do you frame a good challenge?

With an action verb, a motivating action, an affected group and an inspiring goal, and without anticipating the solution: no "system", "campaign" or "app".

Can challenges be run with companies?

Yes. Companies can propose real challenges that teachers bring into the classroom, with mentors from the company and a final presentation to it.

Try it with your class

Design your first experience and launch it with your students

Request your demo: we activate your account with the Experience Designer so you can try it with a real class.

  • 30day trial
  • 1AI-designed experience
  • 30students

Let's talk about your case

Tell us who you are and what you need. We reply within 24 hours, by email or WhatsApp.

What do you need?
How would you prefer to be contacted?

Please confirm you are not a robot.